Pasadena Playhouse
The standard for staging Golden Age musicals is shifting. Audiences love the sweeping romances and soaring melodies but the outdated jokes, passe gender roles, and creaky dialogue can feel out of sync with modern sensibilities.
Enter the Pasadena Playhouse’s production of the 1947 classic Brigadoon, offering a fascinating and edgy modern twist to Lerner and Loewe’s well-known mythical tale. Armed with a thoughtful new book adaptation by actor-turned-playwright Alexandra Silber and directed/choreographed with sweeping energy by Katie Spelman, this revival isn’t just a breath of fresh air; it’s a flat-out triumph.
Rather than lecturing audiences with contemporary theatre’s tiresome and overworked focus on society’s inequities or stripping away the piece's original romantic whimsy, Silber and Spelman deep-clean the original tale, focusing heavily on human connection and genuine grief with an unexpected all-new emphasis on vibrant Scottish culture.
The foundational story remains unchanged: two New Yorkers get hopelessly lost in the Scottish Highlands on vacation, only to stumble across a (literally) enchanted village that appears for only one single day every 100 years to protect itself from the corrupting influences of the outside world.
Silber's book narrows down the timeline. Our travelers are once again city-dwelling buddies, while the village itself is still preserved with all its vestiges of the 1700s. Crucially, however, the outdated caricatures are gone, most notably underplaying smitten villager Fiona MacLaren’s competition for the heart of Tommy Albright back in the Big Apple.
“Including Jane in the story was not serving a good purpose,” believes Silber. “A man choosing between the opportunity to be brave, to grow, seemed like a more interesting story to me than pitting women against each other at its center.”
Also, the town pump Meg Brockie (played with showstopping, boisterous charm by Donna Vivino) is no longer a desperate woman hunting for any man available but instead is portrayed as a vivacious, independent tavern keeper fiercely proud of the Gaelic culture of her village—and of herself—and the original kindly schoolmaster is cleverly reimagined as the town’s beloved spokesperson, played in a notable star turn with an unshakeable lived-in gravitas and quiet humor by the incomparable multiple Tony and Emmy-winning Tyne Daly.
Silber defly deconstructs the former madonna-whore polarity of Alan Jay Lerner’s original text, which leans heavily into dated female archetypes, creating a sharp contrast between the pure and idealized Fiona (Betsy Morgan) and the hyper-sexualized, man-crazy caricature of Meg. Fiona is given a sharper and more fully realized agency and modern interiority; no longer is she depicted as a mooning lass just waiting around for a husband but instead has a rich connection to her community's history.
Vivino's role of Meg undergoes the most radical text lifting, refashioned into a still bawdy yet fiercely independent tavern keeper completely content to be her own woman, shifting her comedic numbers from a desperate hunt for a man to a celebration of autonomous female desire.
Gender-flipping the village's wise academic patriarch Mr. Lundie into Widow Lundie and adding the remarkable performance of Daly to the mix brings a completely different maternal warmth and lived-in authority to the exposition of the town's magical contract with that also mythical old man on the cloud, replacing the musical’s clinical history lesson with an act of communal storytelling. “The hardest thing in the world is to give up everything,” she wisely offers, “even if it often is the only way to get everything.”
All of this could not come across more spectacularly. “What I wanted was to make sure I didn’t paint it with a broad watercolor of a contemporary feminist lens,” Silber explains in the production’s program, “ but to actually bring out and portray that matriarchal ancient society did exist in 18th-century Scotland.”
Further fleshing out the community's background and silent grief, she approached the adaptation with novelistic stage directions, digging into the previously unwritten backstories of the ensemble. This is most vividly executed through the character of Maggie Anderson (Jessica Lee Keller), traditionally a peripheral dancing role. In this version, Maggie is expanded into a central emotional anchor who was rendered mute after losing both of her parents in a past calamity. By giving her a clearer traumatic backstory, her explosive, agonizing Act II funeral dance, jarringly created by Spelman’s Agnes DeMille-centric choreography following the suicide leap of Harry Beaton (Spencer Davis Milford) carries immense thematic weight regarding how a tightly knit community processes collective sorrow.
The playwright and director obviously worked closely together throughout to ensure both the cultural identity of the characters and solidifying that the setting felt authentically Scottish rather than a postcard caricature, something further extended by the precise use of traditional folk roots in Spelman’s driving, athletic choreography which bypasses the standard airy fairyland tropes to deliver an environment that feels tactile, ancient, and deeply human, not only paying homage the spirit of DeMille’s iconic original ballets but introducing a freshly raw, driving vitality.
The absolute luxury of this production is its scale. In a bold move, Pasadena Playhouse places a full 22-piece live orchestra onstage behind Jason Sherwood’s sweepingly charming sets, augmented by a live Ceilidh band complete with bagpipes in full view and directly interacting with the performers. Under Brad Gardner’s lush musical direction and Danny Erdberg and Ursula Kwong-Brown’s electrifying sound, Frederick Loewe’s iconic score swells beautifully, filling the historic 101-year-old house with an intoxicating warmth and musical grandeur.
The vocal performances are uniformly elite. Max von Essen delivers a soaring, elegant tenor as Tommy, infusing the character with an achingly grounded sincerity rather than the typical dopey lovestruck persona. Opposite him, Morgan is simply spectacular, her rich, almost operatic soprano providing the emotional heartbeat of the night—and their duet on the show’s most famous standard, “Almost Like Being in Love,” sends chills straight to the rafters. Also, nothing about the predicable rom-com nature of their relationship, which begins with the feisty Scottish lassie telling the puzzled visitor who doesn’t quite get her town, “I like you very much… I just dinna like anything you say,” emerges as in any way contrived or formulaic.
Happy Anderson is a major standout as Tommy’s best friend and traveling companion Jeff Douglas, the musical’s one non-singing role here turned by Silber from a peripheral second banana into a boisterous, wisecracking drunk who uses his size and humor to hide the incredible pain of losing his beloved wife to cancer. One startlingly memorable and emotionally charged eleventh-hour scene between Anderson and von Essen after the pair has left Brigadoon somehow plays like Odets rather than Lerner—and ironically feels totally in place.
The joyous wedding celebration between Charlie Dalrymple (the charming and big-voiced Daniel Yearwood) and Jean MacLaren (an ethereal Kylie Victoria Edwards) is light and celebratory but still stands in perfect, devastating contrast to the show's emotional climax, something that leaves many in the audience visibly misty-eyed on their way out of the theatre, all ready to go home and tell their absent loved one “There but for you go I” as they declare how much he or she means to them.
Pasadena Playhouse continues its incredible streak of proving why it won the Regional Theatre Tony Award. This fresh and fabulous Brigadoon is beautifully produced, newly balanced, and acted with clarity and enormous heart, proving you don't have to break a Golden Age classic to make it matter to a modern audience—you just have to find its heartbeat. The most indelible personal take away for me energizing the journey through my own unexpectedly passionate golden years came from the Yoda-esque Widow Lundie: “If you love deeply enough, anything can happen.”