Ahmanson Theatre
There is a distinctly surreal wave of familiarity that hits you the moment the lights come up on the 25th anniversary North American tour of Mamma Mia!, currently rocking out in true classic 1990s style at the Ahmanson.
For this reviewer, the feeling was deeply personal as 23 years ago, I briefly stepped into the khakis of Aussie travel writer and possible absent father Bill Austin on tour in this very jukebox juggernaut. To see the exact original scenic and lighting concepts, not to mention Mark Thompson's evocative and colorful wardrobe designs, immaculately reproduced felt like stepping into a time capsule. Every costume cue and sun-bleached movable block of Aegean wall, every saturated blue horizon, remains flawlessly intact, faithfully preserving the aesthetic blueprint originally crafted by the creative team.
What also makes this revival so striking is how faithfully it reproduces the visual poetry of Howard Harrison’s lighting, which doesn't just illuminate Thompson’s minimalist stark-white designs, it fundamentally transforms them. By treating those blocky structures as a blank canvas, Harrison bathes the stage in saturated washes of Mediterranean color, tracking the story across a flawless 24-hour cycle. The shift from the scorching white-gold intensity of midday Greek sunlight to the intoxicating royal blues and aquas of a moonlit beach, creates a vivid atmospheric texture that elevates the entire narrative. And, of course, Harrison’s sudden pivot into blinding stadium-style rock-and-roll concert lighting for the iconic finale produces pure theatrical adrenaline.
Meticulously preserved for this tour, Anthony Van Laast’s choreography remains the true high-octane engine of the production. Van Laast’s genius lies in his ability to make the movement look completely organic and spontaneous, masking the immense athletic discipline required by this tireless ensemble. Whether it’s the kinetic, flipper-clad high male testosterone-infused absurdity of “Lay All Your Love on Me” or the swirling, drunken chaos of the local boys’ stag party, the staging relies on a brilliant sense of comedic geometry. Every leap, kick, and synchronized stomp feels less like a rehearsed dance routine and more like a joyful, uncontrollable eruption of youthful energy, particularly exemplified by Dominic Young as Pepper, whose vital athleticism and unearthly energy singlehandedly keeps the show's engine revving with an infectious jolt of adrenaline whenever he appears onstage.
At the helm of the original blueprint, director Phyllida Lloyd managed a feat that few jukebox musicals ever replicate: she grounded the fluff. Lloyd’s direction strikes a delicate balance, leaning heavily into the broadly farcical comedy of Catherine Johnson's book without losing the maternal emotional core of the piece. On the massive Ahmanson stage, that specific directorial pacing that always energizes the proceedings even when Act Two threatens to drown in rom-com syrup, her staging keeps the momentum crisp, efficiently driving the characters toward their inevitable crowd-pleasing resolutions.
To be completely candid, I've never been an uncritical devotee of Mamma Mia! and might have skipped this revival had it not been for my pal Priscilla Barnes' spirited enthusiasm to see it with me. While Johnson’s dialogue is undeniably clever in how it weaves 90s pop sensibilities and ABBA’s infectious pop discography into a coherent narrative, the material itself is a tale of two acts and has always remained for me a case of the book vs. the beat. Act One remains an absolute blast—a high-energy, spontaneous sprint of pure musical confection, while Act Two tends to lose its footing and get bogged down in a saccharine sentimentality that stretches past its expiration date.
Yet, if the material occasionally sags, this touring company fights like hell to keep it afloat. Spontaneity is usually the first casualty of a long road tour, but this ensemble delivers an insanely high-octane performance that feels brand new. Yet if there’s a true MVP in this iteration, it is the production’s dynamic live orchestra. Under the driving baton of musical director Andrew David Sotomayor, the invisible contribution from the pit is spectacularly on point, nailing the highly specific wall-of-sound texture required to make these iconic tracks soar and providing a rhythmic heartbeat that elevates the entire evening.
When it comes to the frontline cast, however, it’s a tale of two genders here, as the women of the fictional island of Kalokairi (which by the way means “summer" in Greek) comfortably outshine their male counterparts. Sophie’s three potential fathers, by contrast, feel a bit paint-by-number.
Rob Hancock, in for Rob Marnell as Harry “Headbanger” Bright, earns a generous pass—something of which I clearly identify in this very show, as when I did it I was a nearly rehearsal-free replacement for an ailing replacement. Hancock delivered a commendable performance, as did Jason Mulay as Sophie’s fiancé Sky, also stepping up from the ranks for Grant Reynolds and handling the track with solid professionalism.
As Sam Carmichael, Victor Wallace, a former Sky at the Mandalay Bay in Las Vegas during its long run there in his earlier years, easily possesses one of the finest and most resonant singing voices in the entire company, but sadly feels the need to lean into the overly mannered. There is a self-satisfied and posturing full-of-himself Cagney quality to his interpretation that robs the character of the vulnerability and appeal the role desperately needs.
Leland Burnett as Bill presents the production’s biggest conundrum—certainly not in his abilities but in his casting. While everything else in this remounting presents a faithful reproduction of the original, the creative choice to transform the traditionally scruffy, slouchy Australian travel writer into an awe-shucks lanky Texan is baffling. Bursting with good ol’ boy energy and a distinct Buddy Ebsen flavor, the characterization misses the mark for me. This departure becomes especially jarring during his second-act mismatched romantic showdown with Rosie (a superlative Carly Sakolove), undercutting what should be a brilliantly balanced comedic duet.
Still, it’s the women to the rescue here, as it’s the female principals who make this production sing, if you’ll excuse the pun. Making a tremendous national tour debut, Juliet M. Ojeda is a standout as Sophie—vibrant, clear-voiced, and palpably grounded, she delivers a performance so strong that she actually uncharacteristicly overshadows Jessica Crouch as her mother for a large portion of the evening. That dynamic shifts beautifully late in Act Two when Crouch delivers an eleventh-hour rendition of Donna's iconic ballad “The Winner Takes All” that absolutely knocks her performance into a whole new level, grounding the emotional stakes right when the show needs it the most.
Of course, no mounting of Mamma Mia! succeeds without Donna's visiting besties, the former backup singers from her youthful girl band Donna and the Dynamos. The lighthearted heavy lifting here is effortlessly shared between Sakolove’s gently over-the-hill Rosie and Jalynn Steele as a vaguely jive-talking yet slightly Eve Arden-shaded Tanya. They are an absolute riot together, striking up a delicious, sharply-timed chemistry that anchors the show’s best comedic beats.
Steele plays the thrice-married Tanya with a delightfully biting world-weary sophistication, while Sakolove balances her perfectly with an earthy and wonderfully unhinged warmth. Whether they are reviving the spirits of their old friend or commanding the stage during their respective second-act showstoppers, this formidable duo ensures that the beloved characters’ legendary sisterhood is in spectacularly capable hands.
In the end, Mamma Mia! remains the ultimate theatrical paradox: a show with a second act that sags like a wet hammock and packs enough artificial sweetener to induce a diabetic coma, yet possesses a score so infectious it should probably be studied by the CDC. Despite its one baffling creative choice—seriously, I still don't know why Bill is suddenly pacing around the Aegean as though he’s looking for an oil rig—this otherwise by-the-book revival manages to outrun its own shortcomings.
My old touring khakis may be long retired and surely would never fit me anymore anyway, but thanks to this nostalgic reworking, with its adrenaline-fueled ensemble and a pit orchestra that refuses to sleep on the job, the party is still going strong. It’s a spirited, high-octane reminder of why this juggernaut keeps rolling. Just leave your critical cynicism at the door, embrace the dazzling sequins flashing in your eyes, and let the nostalgia wash over you as the party happening right now at the Ahmanson is still going strong.
So, is Mamma Mia! high art? Heavens, no. Still, you’ll leave the theatre with “Dancing Queen” trapped in your head for the next 72 hours at least. Thanks to its powerhouse female castmembers supported by a gung-ho stageful of somewhat overlooked singer-dancer-set movers and a pit orchestra that refuses to sleep on the job, this anniversary tour proves when it comes to pure, unadulterated musical escapism, ABBA still takes it all. Go for the music and Honey, Honey, enjoy the ride.