A WORK IN PROGRESS!!! NOT YET FOR PUBLICATION! SHHHHHHH!!!

 

 

With all the ongoing challenges facing the LA theatre community, I’ve still gotta say it’s been a smash of a year—especially for playwrights and directors, it seems, as I see how my 34th annual TicketHolder Awards have unfolded.

It’s clearly a given that Best Season honors should go to Rogue Machine. I begin compiling and adding to my nomination choices from the beginning of each year and now that this year’s choices have all come together, even I am gobsmacked that the first friggin’ five shows on my list for Best Production were all mounted by this one prolific and uber-talented company. What a remarkable achievement!

Although I’ve never before awarded special Living Legend recognition, how could I not this year as Dick Van Dyke, someone I’ve known and loved since our days working together in Bye Bye Birdie in 1960 when he was 35 and I was 13, turned a remarkable 100 years old on December 13th. Dick is one of my life’s most exalted mentors, a guy with an unstoppable energy and zest for life who has been an inspiration to me for the past 65 years. Huzzah!

There was a puzzlement in my mind as to where to put any recognition for the phenomenal Stereophonic, which played here at the Pantages after becoming the Best Play Tony Award winner in New York last year. Certainly, it could be categorized as a play with music, but in light of the incredible (yet too briefly featured) score by Arcade Fire’s Will Butler and the knockout musical performances by its stellar ensemble cast, to me it fit better for Best Musical consideration. And if Anora and The Substance could receive nominations in last year’s Golden Globes as Best Musical or Comedy, my decision is a minor one in comparison, right? Besides, in this LA theatre season chockful with incredible choices to recognize, there was more room here in the Best Musical section—a side benefit afforded me for 34 years compiling my own awards, so fuck it.

 

SPECIAL LIVING LEGEND AWARD 

Dick Van Dyke 

 

BEST SEASON OF 2025

 Rogue Machine

 

BEST PLAYS OF 2025

Corktown ’39, Rogue Machine

Reel to Reel, Rogue Machine

Evanston Salt Costs Rising, Rogue Machine

Bacon, Rogue Machine

Anthropology, Rogue Machine

The Reservoir, Geffen Playhouse

Tasty Little Rabbit, Moving Arts Theatre

A Doll's House, Part 2, Pasadena Playhouse

Swipe, Playwrights' Arena

Harry Potter and the Cursed Child, Pantages Theatre 

Here There Are Blueberries, Wallis Annenberg Center for the Performing Arts 

Hamlet, Center Theatre Group, Mark Taper Forum

Hide and Hide, Skylight Theatre

Paranormal Activity, Center Theatre Group, Ahmanson Theatre

Jaja's African Hair Braiding, Center Theatre Group, Mark Taper Forum 

Sleeping Giant, Road Theatre Company  

Life of Pi, Center Theatre Group, Ahmanson Theatre 

 

BEST REVIVAL PRODUCTIONS

Parade, Center Theatre Group, Ahmanson Theatre

The Night of the Iguana, Boston Court Performing Arts Center 

Heisenberg, Skylight Theatre

The Glass Menagerie, Antaeus Theatre Company

Noises Off, Geffen Playhouse

Yankee Dawg You Die, East West Players 

Bat Boy: The Musical, Open Fist Theatre Company

 

BEST MUSICAL PRODUCTIONS

Suffs, Pantages Theatre

Stereophonic, Pantages Theatre

UnRavelled, Wallis Annenberg Center for the Performing Arts

Old Friends, Center Theatre Group, Ahmanson Theatre

The Wedding Singer, Colony Theatre  

A Man of No Importance, A Noise Within

Cambodian Rock Band, East West Players

Some Like It Hot, Pantages Theatre

& Juliet, Center Theatre Group, Ahmanson Theatre

A Beautiful Noise, Pantages Theatre

Shucked, Pantages Theatre 

 

THE WHAT-WERE-THEY-THINKING AWARD 2025

Death of a Salesman, Panic! Productions at the Colony Theatre