Blue Pen Theatre Company
What a joy it is to see Charles Mee’s work back on Los Angeles stages this season after an entirely too long absence. First came City Garage’s magical production of Limonade Tous Les Jours and now the ambitious, discerning fledgling Blue Pen Theatre Company is presenting the LA premiere of Mee’s Tunnel of Love. Adding to the occasion is the setting: the site-specific Majic Factory, housed inside the historic 1908 Echo Park Clubhouse and Library—the very first location ever maintained by the Los Angeles Recreation and Parks Department.
The play itself, dubbed a “kaleidoscope of love stories” in classic Mee fashion, eschews conventional linear narrative to assemble a collage of human connection: wild, messy, sublime, and sometimes painful. Characters collide, confess, dance, and debate, offering a vibrant tapestry of romance in both its most vulnerable and most chaotic permutations.
Back in 2004, I had the privilege of playing Frank in the LA premiere of Mee’s Summertime—the second production to inaugurate the then-new Boston Court Performing Arts Center, brilliantly directed by Michael Michetti and featuring an early glimpse of the extraordinary Tessa Thompson playing my daughter.
It was an absolute flashback for me that early in Tunnel of Love, Nika Burnett as the romancaphobic Ziya launched into the monologue about how each of us has only one true love in life. It was the exact same monologue I delivered to open Act Two of our production 22 years ago.
That cross-pollination of text speaks directly to Mee’s generously open-sourcing theatrical philosophy. He famously encourages artists to dismantle, reassemble, and freely interpret his texts. That same artistic freedom explains why Nalini Sharma here delivers a blistering monologue railing against men—complete with a string of penis jokes—that was originally delivered in our Summertime production by the incomparable Sandy Martin (the grandmother in Napoleon Dynamite and Sam Rockwell’s mother in Three Billboards Outside Ebbing, Missouri).
Blue Pen deserves real praise for their sheer bravado and a nothing-stops-us quest to bring such incredible and frequently overlooked works to our scrappy local theatre community, this second outing following their maiden production last season of Aaron Posner’s Stupid Fucking Bird—coincidentally another play I had the honor of doing in its LA debut, also under Michetti’s guidance at the Boston Court.
What stands out most here is the pure ambition and resourcefulness of this young cast. Burnett, Sharma, Solomon Astley, Amanda Perez, Joel Allen, Jodi Moore Lewis, Alessandro Marino, and Nick Samson operate as a remarkably cohesive, gamely onboard ensemble, with Burnett and Lewis offering especially grounded and compelling stand-out work throughout the evening.
Adding to the production's ingenuity is the inventive addition of live music, with bandleader Brett Rojas on drums, Lein Escudero on keyboards, and Matthew Perez on bass and guitar providing a dynamic soundtrack backed by Burnett delivering some impressive vocal stylings.
Director Mark Sitka handles the difficult playing space with tremendously fluid, engaging staging, well-complemented by Chrissy Harding’s energetic choreography. The performances are effective overall, showcasing a rare passion for tackling difficult, unsanitized material on a lean budget. My only operational critique concerns the acoustic environment: in a two-sided audience configuration and considering the venue’s high vaulted ceiling, when actors turn away from one section, Mee’s not-to-be-missed dialogue too often gets lost. The addition of subtle body mics would easily solve the issue and keep every word intact.
Ultimately, Blue Pen’s production honors the foundational ethos of Chuck Mee’s worldview. Back in 2004, when I interviewed the playwright for Entertainment Today, he attributed the decline of American theatre to the "triumph of naturalism and the well-made play, which is boring people crazy out of their minds." Instead, Mee championed a return to the "immense energies" of the Greek classics and Shakespeare, a theatre that encompasses spectacle, music, dance, color, and noise alongside text.
As Mee explained from his home in New York at the time, "So much of our theatre and movies make us stupid and ill-prepared to live our lives because they seduce us into believing that human destiny is worked out only in the intimacy of one-on-one relationships. I like plays that are not too neat, too finished, too presentable. My plays are broken, jagged, filled with sharp edges, filled with things that take sudden turns. They careen into each other, smash up, veer off in sickening turns. That feels good to me. It feels like my life. And then I like to put this chaotic stuff into a classical form.
"Things invade each other all the time, so if you collage material and let farce live side-by-side with horror, plays can turn on a dime the way real life does. I've come to believe that art is most pleasurable not when it closes us down, narrows our perceptions and sympathies, draws boundaries of appropriateness or goodness, but when it opens us up."
That commitment to juxtaposition—high and low, tragic and farcical, intellectual and physical—demands a rare kind of courage from performers. When Michael Michetti directed us in Summertime, he gave us all a piece of advice that remains the ultimate barometer for any company tackling Mee’s canon: "Be brave, commit to the language, the physicality, the passion, the jagged journey, and find the place where that reality meets your heart. I think that’s where Chuck’s plays live."
In the historic yet raw space of a former Echo Park Craftsman clubhouse, Blue Pen’s spirited cast accepted that very invitation. They brought bravery, resourcefulness, and undeniable heart to Mee’s jagged and beautiful world—and Los Angeles theatre is all the richer for their commitment.