Rogue Machine
It has come to my attention just now that listening to Debussy’s Clair du lune while attempting to write about a new play by Justin Tanner is simply not feasible. I’m not sure what is. Scriabin, maybe? Or Stockhausen? Varese? Yoko Ono?
Tanner, whose early works at the now iconic Cast Theatre beginning in the late 80s, such as the Pen West Award winner Pot Mom, as well as Teen Girl, Coyote Woman, Tent Show, Bitter Women, and the 10-year run of Zombie Attack, not only began the careers of such artists as Laurie Metcalf and French Stewart, it put our scrappy Los Angeles intimate theatre scene on the map and made the LACC-bred playwright something of a living local legend.
I had the privilege of working alongside Tanner in that other LA theatre counter-culture superstar Michael Sargent’s American Nympho in the late night serial The Strip: A Living Comic Book at the lost and dearly lamented Evidence Room in 2002, where each week us game performers would receive our scripts by Thursday night, rehearse once, and then each Saturday at midnight would perform new uber-wacky live episodes of three mock soap opera stories by Tanner, Sargent, and Patricia Scanlon as her notorious Hildy Hildy in what the LA Times then referred to as “savagely funny renegade hilarity” reminiscent of “R. Crumb meets the Cockettes on a bender.”
In 2009, Tanner’s Voice Lessons, in a much-extended run at the Zephyr and later Sacred Fools, also starring his then-fervent disciples Metcalf and Stewart, was swamped with award nominations, but it was his newsmaking antics with his 2005 production Oklahomo! at a small theatre in Burbank that raised the writer to undying eminence for me.
Justin’s deliciously irreverent take on one of the 20th century’s sappiest musicals featured a small gay theatre company presenting an unauthorized all-male version of the classic Oklahoma!—and the playwright brazenly typecast himself as the show’s abrasive director who suffers a nervous breakdown during rehearsals.
When the Rodgers and Hammerstein Foundation found out about the production, they immediately issued an official Cease and Desist order demanding the production be shut down. Instead of stopping performances, however, Justin Tanner wrote in a new ending scene, with representatives from the Foundation (played by actors) rushing from the back of the house shouting “STOP!” and waving court orders. Oklahomo! defiantly continued its run to sold out houses.
Anyone who knows Justin knows his performance as that out-of-control director in Oklahomo! was hardly a stretch for the guy. Tanner’s personal reputation for being a tad… volatile, may I say?… is nearly as notorious in LA theatre circles as his outrageously off-centered and genuinely hilarious plays themselves.
In his maturing years, Justin has come to work diligently on his demons—and his plays have become more and more autobiographical along the way. Such was definitely the case with his last offering, Little Theatre, which three years ago began his tenure as Rogue Machine’s resident playwright and almost uncomfortably dredged up his early years and lingering trauma initiated during his beginnings at the Cast Theatre.
Still, as Justin conjectures in My Son the Playwright, his newest and most autobiographical play yet, now debuting in Rogue Machine’s upstairs second space, “trauma can be really good for creativity.” If that truly is the case, Justin Tanner’s theatrical fertility might be entering its epic stages.
When I first heard that this new work was more personal than any that came before it and Tanner would be performing it as a solo play, I have to say my first reaction was a bit apprehensive. Although I consider this guy a longtime friend-adjacent, when I wrote a review of Little Theatre that wasn’t exactly a rave, I had the impression my opinion wasn’t exactly taken as constructive criticism.
I decided to brave the possible upcoming firestorm to check out My Son the Playwright and I’m glad I did. Indeed, this is Tanner’s most personal play and as so, it’s not only both courageous and painful, it ultimately emerges as a fascinating monograph laying bare how personal compulsions can foster something akin to great art—and how life’s repeated letdowns and early familial cruelty can blur the edges between them. “Disappointment,” we’re reassured, “breeds character.”
In a two-act format, Tanner plays both a young El Lay playwright overwhelmed by massive career disappointments—obsessively fueled by drugs, alcohol, and a penchant for casual sex (“It’s like popping Kit Kats”)—and his equally dysfunctional rage-prone father who sees himself as even more of a victim than his son does.
Both characters kvetch incessantly about the other and how they’ve been treated, something that emerges most of the time as though we, the audience, are a cadre of mental health professionals studying a subject trapped in front of us like a character on an episode of Twilight Zone being studied by aliens.
Act One begins with a ringing phone in a cramped and blandly impersonal empty apartment (a perfect canvas for designer Mark Mendelson in the former Matrix’s tiny upstairs storeroom turned into a unique playing space in 2023) until Douglas, the father in question, emerges angrily from a side room accompanied by the sound of a flushing toilet.
It’s his son James on the phone, whose tardiness in his promised visit to Douglas’ Monterey Peninsula home has already reached the three-hour mark. When he finally ends the call, Douglas turns to us to lash out about what a loser his kid is. “He’s a playwright,” he shares in his frustration. “Not exactly the field a dad wants his son to go into.”
During his 45-minute rage-filled diatribe going off on his offspring, he all but kills an entire decanter of gin but somewhere, although he blames his “succubus” ex-wife for James’ many problems, underneath there’s another layer where a well-hidden and somewhat twisted love for his son lingers—as well as a bit of jealousy that James openly embraced his homosexual nature while he spent his entire life suppressing his own similar tendencies.
After a break to rearrange furniture and add a few movie posters to indicate the son’s equally claustrophobic LA apartment, Tanner reappears looking equally distraught under a youthful wig as James frantically searches the place for his missing bag of weed while letting us know how agonizing it is to drive up the coast to see his father without being sufficiently wasted.
The two men, although each rants to us about the horrors of dealing with the other, are in many ways like the same person. This is something Tanner, with the help of his longtime directorial collaborator Lisa James, works hard to overcome with subtle body language. Where Douglas has the tendency to physically pull into himself and bend deeply from the waist to somehow make himself smaller, James’ demeanor is large and even commanding, arms spread apart grandly to make his points.
It may be an understatement to say My Son the Playwright is exhausting, although it must be even more exhausting for Justin Tanner than it is for his audience. His performance is a huge commitment to his characters but hopefully, as the run settles in a tad, I think the play would be better served if it could be a little less frenetic and in-your-face.
I would think for even the most unfamiliar with the massive outpouring of work by Tanner, it would be nearly impossible not to realize how psychobiographical the piece is. At one point, when a quickie with an anonymous partner ends, his trick whispers into James’ ear, “By the way, I loved your play Pot Mom." It’s clear the line between fiction and reality is somewhat intentionally breached here.
My Son the Playwright is a phenomenal achievement, ironically both selfish and unselfish at the same time. Still, it’s impossible to leave the theatre without feeling, although you’ve been privy to something that in lesser and less comedically genius hands than Justin Tanner’s, as though you’ve been bombarded with more raw personal information than most people might want to absorb. I left not quite sure if I wanted to go home and write this review or to see if I could snag my monumentally talented though sometimes uncomfortably manic friend a prescription for Risperadone.